Influencer Culture The Comment Section as Community: Real or Fake? Mercy Idoko IfunanyaJuly 26, 202501K views Some people believe that the internet is where genuine friendships form. Others say it’s full of noise. But in today’s world, comment sections are busy. Whether under a viral video or a news post, thousands of people join the chat. A report by Pew Research found that about 40% of internet users say they often read comment sections, even if they don’t participate in the discussion. That says a lot. People may scroll past the main post, but they stop for the comments. Why? Maybe for laughs. Maybe to feel seen. Or maybe, they just want to be part of something. But here’s the big question: do these comment threads bring people together? Or is it all just noise pretending to be a community? Signs That Comment Sections Feel Real Comment sections can feel like more than just text on a screen. Sometimes, they feel like home. Here are a few signs that show when they feel real: 1. The Same People Keep Coming Back A strong sign that a comment section feels real is when you notice familiar names popping up again and again. These users don’t just comment once and leave. They return for every new post, video, or update. When the same people consistently show up, it creates a sense of place. It’s like walking into a small café where everyone nods at each other. Over time, short replies can grow into full chats, and strangers can start feeling like neighbours. This kind of repeated presence is how trust and comfort start to grow. It shows people care, not just about the post, but about the people in the space. 2. Kind Words and Real Support Another clear sign of a real online community is when people offer support. Sometimes, someone drops a comment saying they’re having a rough day. Perhaps they’ve lost a job, feel alone, or simply need someone to talk to. In some comment sections, that post would be ignored. But in a space that feels real, it gets seen and met with kindness. Some will share tips or gentle advice. Others may just leave a heart emoji or a prayer hand. These little acts go a long way. Even though they don’t know each other in real life, people choose to care. That care creates warmth, and warmth makes the space feel safe. In that moment, the comment section isn’t just about the main post. It’s about people showing up for each other. And that’s what makes it feel real. 3. Inside Jokes and Shared Language In some comment sections, you’ll notice certain jokes or phrases come up again and again. These aren’t just random. They’re little signs that people have built a shared style. Maybe someone said something funny weeks ago, and now others keep repeating it. Or there’s a nickname for the creator that everyone uses. This kind of shared language shows people feel at home there. It gives the space a sense of “us.” Even new users can join in, making it feel like a friendly circle. It’s small, but it’s how online bonds grow. 4. Helpful Replies to Real Questions When someone asks a genuine question and receives honest answers, it changes the tone of a comment section. It might be advice on a topic, help with a task, or even emotional support. Instead of ignoring the comment, people take time to respond with care. This shows the group isn’t just there for laughs or drama. They’re also willing to help. And that’s what makes a space feel like a true community. It’s not just about sharing opinions, it’s about being useful and kind when someone needs it. READ MORE Are Influencers the New Community Elders? What This Means for Culture & Youth in 2025 Is Gen Z Slang Replacing Nigerian Proverbs—or Just Evolving Them? Soft-Spoken Nigerian Influencers: Why Calm Voices Are Winning Hearts in 2025 Signs That It’s Not a Real Community Some comment sections appear active but lack the elements that make a genuine community. These signs show when it might just be noise, not a genuine connection. 1. Hate, Trolls, and Fights Everywhere In some comment sections, the main thing you’ll find is trouble. People throw harsh words, mock others, or try to start fights. These are often referred to as trolls who post intentionally to upset people. When hate spreads, even kind users leave. It pushes away care and support, which are essential components of any genuine community. Instead of lifting each other, the space becomes a mess of anger and hurt. A real community should feel safe, not scary. 2. No One Uses a Real Name or Identity Most comment sections are full of usernames. That’s fine, but when everyone hides behind fake names and no one shares even a little truth about themselves, trust is hard to build. In real life, communities grow because people know each other. They share small bits of their lives, even if just a first name or feeling. When no one is open, even a little, it turns the space into a place where no one knows or cares about anyone else. The Role of Platforms and Algorithms Social media apps use algorithms to choose which comments people see first. Funny, bold, or popular replies often rise to the top, while quiet or thoughtful ones may get buried. Sometimes the system hides harmful comments to keep things safe. But it can also block good ones by mistake. This can shape the whole vibe of the space. When the system works well, it helps good voices shine. However, when it prioritises only loud or viral posts, it can make the space feel fake or cluttered. Ultimately, platforms significantly influence the perceived authenticity of a comment section. Conclusion Comment sections can feel like real communities, but not always. It depends on how people act and how the platform works. When kindness, care, and support are present, the space can feel warm and welcoming. But when hate, noise, or fake attention takes over, it loses that human touch. In the end, it’s the people who make the difference. Showcase Nigeria Through Your Lens – Join Our Open Call for Creators Are you a photographer, videographer, or content creator passionate about capturing Nigeria’s beauty, from fashion runways and cultural festivals to tourist landmarks and local events? Our Open Call for Content Creators in Nigeria is your opportunity to get featured, collaborate, and bring authentic Nigerian stories to life. Whether you’re into travel, lifestyle, or visual storytelling, we want to see Nigeria through your eyes. Explore more on how influencer culture is shaping life in Nigeria. Frequently Asked Questions 1. Can Comment Sections Help People Feel Less Alone? Yes. Supportive replies and kind words can make users feel seen and cared for. 2. Why Do Some Comment Sections Feel Toxic? A lack of rules, trolls, and rewards for loud posts often leads to a toxic space. 3. Are Online Friendships From Comments Real? They can be. Many people build lasting bonds by chatting often in comment sections. 4. How Can I Stay Safe When Joining a Comment Section? Avoid sharing personal details, report harmful comments, and stick to kind spaces.